In the last couple of weeks, as the ALS Ice Bucket Challenge has continued to spread, some questions have arisen about the ALS Association. A lot of people have stated, on social media and elsewhere, that they feel ethically or morally unable to contribute to the ALS Association because of a study funded by the ALSA that includes research into embryonic stem cell research. This concern has gone more or less viral in certain communities, some of which I happen to affiliate myself with. In some cases, people have outright dismissed the challenge and the idea of participating altogether. I've responded as best I can via Facebook to individuals, but this has spread so far now that I felt compelled to write up my thoughts here to share with you.
If you are reading this, you probably know that both my grandmother Jean and my mom Lillian died from ALS, in 1979 and 2011 respectively. The Ice Bucket Challenge timing really affected me, because Mom died three years ago this week. With that in mind, it's hard not to take the cynical, the dismissive, even the well-meaning critics of the ALS Association and the challenge poorly. Put bluntly, a lot of the comments have hurt. A lot.
Before I go further, let me state that I am pro-life. My mother was a very active pro-life advocate; she counseled young women when she was in the Navy, and she remained active in the Catholic Church, the Ladies' Auxiliary of the Knights of Columbus and other groups in promoting the pro-life message. And she was very motivated to actually help those in need as opposed to simply talking about it. That's the environment I grew up in.
I am not affiliated with The ALS Association, and I don't speak for them. My family did receive help from our local chapter when Mom was sick. I will say that I think that the ALSA takes a very broad-based approach to ALS research, and I don't fault them for that at all, even if I have ethical concerns about embryonic stem cell research. We're talking about a disease that medical science has almost no answers for. They don't know precisely what causes it (if it's all genetic, which environmental factors may contribute), how to prevent it, how to slow it down, how to cure it. It strikes seemingly at random, but then it occasionally runs in families, it strikes veterans at a high rate (especially Vietnam and Gulf War vets). People have been diagnosed as young as 21 (Stephen Hawking) and as old as 70. The scientists studying ALS have to look everywhere. I can't - I will not - blame them for choosing to look everywhere.
But.
I understand, very well, the arguments against embryonic stem cell research, which I will not rehash here. And with that in mind, I understand as well that there are people who want to help but who cannot in good conscience give to the ALSA because of those arguments.
So where do we go from there?
A few general thoughts.
1 - Find another organization to give money to. The John Paul II Medical Research Institute is a good start. If you would rather a non-denominational or non-religious organization, I recommend my mother's favorite charitable cause, the Paralyzed Veterans of America. The PVA was extremely helpful to my family during my mother's illness, and because ALS is a paralyzing disease, veterans with ALS may find help there. Finally, the ALS Foundation for Life is focused more on helping patients and less on research (an ALS patient may spend more than $100,000 on assistive equipment and medical supplies during illness).
2 - Be mindful of what you say, and how you say it, on social media. Remember that you don't know who in your circles may be suffering (I have discovered that three friends have family members awaiting diagnosis of ALS, and I've lost count of how many people I know personally had someone in their lives die from ALS). The Ice Bucket Challenge is goofy in nature, but it had a very serious beginning and it has a very serious purpose. Be mindful of what you say.
3 - ALS may not be the cause you should take up. We all have someone and something we care about, and it is truly impossible to help everyone everywhere with everything. I have a cousin whose passion is organ donation, because her husband suffered from a lung disease for which the only cure was a double-lung transplant. My mother-in-law is a breast cancer survivor. My brother has spina bifida. And so on. We have to pick and choose which causes to support - this is the nature of our reality. So maybe you should help with Alzheimer's research and care, or cancer, or MS, or cerebral palsy, or autism, or any number of other causes. I think the real challenge is to stop and help whenever and however you can.
I will leave you with this. My mother was diagnosed not because there is a test for ALS, but through a process of elimination. When she showed up at her doctor's office with slurred speech, having trouble swallowing, the first tests were for thyroid and brain cancer. It took weeks to get a real answer and again, there was no test for it. It was just that everything else was eliminated. She had a speech machine not unlike this one. When she lost the use of her leg muscles, she was wheelchair-bound, in a motorized chair. The house had to be retrofitted to accommodate the chair and her new special needs. She needed a feeding tube, and special nutritional drinks that could be fed to her through the tube. Eventually she needed a hospital bed. A home health nurse. Special dental work to protect her mouth once she could no longer close it. She was prone to bed sores and pneumonia because of her immobility, and so needed treatment for that. I will spare you a full accounting of what kind of care she needed daily, but I am sure you can imagine.
What we need, even as desperately as we need research and development, is practical help for patients and caregivers. Find a way to help. Don't dismiss the cause because of one issue with one organization.
Remember my mother.
Showing posts with label als. Show all posts
Showing posts with label als. Show all posts
Thursday, August 21, 2014
Tuesday, August 19, 2014
The ALS Ice Bucket Challenge
My #IceBucketChallenge Response: http://youtu.be/axJDigsWNPE
On this, the third anniversary of Mom's passing, I want to share my thoughts on the Ice Bucket Challenge.
Tuesday, March 18, 2014
hindsight
I haven't posted in quite some time. This post isn't me coming back, not really. It is just about passing on information.
This blog started because of a day in 2008, when I realized the process of losing my mother had begun, was already quite progressed, before any of us had a chance to realize what was happening.
It isn't hypochondria to have odd symptoms and go to a doctor with questions. It's responsible. My mother was likely sick for a long time; symptoms we didn't press her to have looked at now, in hindsight, feel like red flags.
ALS mimics other diseases. Some of its symptoms may also signal MS, thyroid issues, or in the case of someone the doctor in the link below knows, a slipped disk. The point is - know your body, know what is normal and what isn't, and go to the doctor.
Saturday, May 25, 2013
two degrees from ALS
May is ALS Awareness Month.
That very phrase strikes an odd note with me. I feel like the concentrated publicity and public outreach that is supposed to take place during an "awareness" month should be a year-round occurrence I mean, this is a disease that invariably kills - there is no cure. It has no discernible pattern, except that we know it sometimes runs in families, that there may be a genetic marker, but that it also occurs randomly, it hits veterans at a greater rate than any other population segment. You can live for decades with it - see Stephen Hawking - or just a couple of years past diagnosis - see Lou Gehrig.
So here's my pitch. You probably don't personally know anyone with ALS. Chances are, you probably won't in the future. But you know me, because you're reading this blog, and my mother and my grandmother were both ALS patients. So your connection to ALS is really just two degrees.
Take a minute and get educated.
I don't expect everyone who learns about ALS to donate money to the cause of finding a cure. This is one of my causes because it hit home, not because of a celebrity or even because of a neighbor or friend-of-a-friend. Certainly not because I read some blog posts about it. But, consider this, if you've got $10 to spare. As the disease progresses, ALS patients require full-time care. Many need wheelchairs early on, they need medical equipment like oxygen masks and tanks, feeding tubes, catheters, all the attendant supplies. Some need caregivers at home, others need to be in homes. Insurance does a lot, but it doesn't do nearly enough, and not every ALS patient has the resources of the VA like my mother did. The ALS Association is mostly focused on research, but if you can find a way to help them or, even better, caregivers and patients directly, you're doing a lot. (updated: in light of the Ice Bucket Challenge and ethical concerns raised about the ALSA's funding of embryonic stem cell research, I have listed out other charitable causes that you can help in this post).
I'm not the hopeful type, when we're talking about ALS. It is really difficult to fathom a cure, when we have so few effective treatments. But comfort, having a support group, responsible end-of-life care, these are things I think we can give ALS patients.
Consider it.
And pass on the word.
That very phrase strikes an odd note with me. I feel like the concentrated publicity and public outreach that is supposed to take place during an "awareness" month should be a year-round occurrence I mean, this is a disease that invariably kills - there is no cure. It has no discernible pattern, except that we know it sometimes runs in families, that there may be a genetic marker, but that it also occurs randomly, it hits veterans at a greater rate than any other population segment. You can live for decades with it - see Stephen Hawking - or just a couple of years past diagnosis - see Lou Gehrig.
So here's my pitch. You probably don't personally know anyone with ALS. Chances are, you probably won't in the future. But you know me, because you're reading this blog, and my mother and my grandmother were both ALS patients. So your connection to ALS is really just two degrees.
![]() |
| Christmas 2009 - Me with Mom in her hospital room. This was thankfully the only Christmas she spent in the hospital. |
Take a minute and get educated.
I don't expect everyone who learns about ALS to donate money to the cause of finding a cure. This is one of my causes because it hit home, not because of a celebrity or even because of a neighbor or friend-of-a-friend. Certainly not because I read some blog posts about it. But, consider this, if you've got $10 to spare. As the disease progresses, ALS patients require full-time care. Many need wheelchairs early on, they need medical equipment like oxygen masks and tanks, feeding tubes, catheters, all the attendant supplies. Some need caregivers at home, others need to be in homes. Insurance does a lot, but it doesn't do nearly enough, and not every ALS patient has the resources of the VA like my mother did. The ALS Association is mostly focused on research, but if you can find a way to help them or, even better, caregivers and patients directly, you're doing a lot. (updated: in light of the Ice Bucket Challenge and ethical concerns raised about the ALSA's funding of embryonic stem cell research, I have listed out other charitable causes that you can help in this post).
I'm not the hopeful type, when we're talking about ALS. It is really difficult to fathom a cure, when we have so few effective treatments. But comfort, having a support group, responsible end-of-life care, these are things I think we can give ALS patients.
Consider it.
And pass on the word.
Monday, April 29, 2013
unpublished
I submitted this essay to a blog recently, and it didn't make the cut. I spent a good amount of time trying to make the words come together - that is to say, writing - and I'd rather put this out in the world than have it languish on my hard drive. If you've read any part of this blog, none of this is new or surprising. This was my path to motherhood.
-
In August of 2011, I found myself doing the one thing I had spent a long time trying to avoid.
I went to my mother’s funeral in a maternity dress, because I was five months pregnant.
I wasn’t planning on getting pregnant. My mother was diagnosed with ALS, Lou Gehrig’s disease, in the fall of 2008. I was anxious to avoid the emotional upheaval of pregnancy on top of the horror of my mother’s disease. It was a horror story from my childhood, in a way. Mom had been two months pregnant with me when her own mother died, and she never got to tell her. She told me the story over the years with tears in her eyes, bitterness in her voice. On some level, I promised, it wouldn’t happen to me.
Pregnancy and motherhood are really things that all the talks and reading in the world can’t prepare you for. But age-old motherly wisdom is supposed to be helpful. I wouldn’t really know. We never talked about it, and then when it happened, my mother couldn’t talk at all.
In the spring of 2011, working long hours and not paying close attention to birth control, I got pregnant. By this time, my mother was bedridden and could no longer smile or laugh. The second I knew for sure, I called to tell her, my dad holding the phone up to her ear. He told me she looked at him and he could tell she heard me, her eyes said everything.
My mother-in-law took me shopping for maternity clothes. We looked around at the nicer dresses, ones that I could later wear while breastfeeding. She told me to pick out something pretty, for going out to dinner. I picked something black, thinking I might need it for a funeral.
It is easy to spend a lot of time worrying about what can go wrong when you’re pregnant, especially when you carry the burden of genetic disorders. We have a history in our family of spina bifida, and I wanted, needed to talk to my mother about her experience when my brother was born with it – I wanted reassurance, I wanted to hear her refute the statistics and tell me my baby would be fine. When I asked, she blinked, the last thing she could do, and her gaze shifted away.
So I asked for every test I could get, not wanting to be caught off-guard. And everything was fine – I was tired, and that was all. My doctor grinned and told me, get more sleep. You’ll need it, he said.
It was difficult to accept all of this. It was strange, to know nothing was going wrong, when it seemed everyone I knew had a horror story – up to and including my own mother. And I was cursing the timing of it all. I was sad and angry, and had a hard time with joy in those first few months. It made me a terrible friend, and a hard person to get along with.
The call from my dad came late on a Friday afternoon. It was unbearably hot outside, the way Texas summers always are. The first time I felt nauseous while I was pregnant was in the wake of that phone call.
During her wake, I spent a lot of time answering questions about my tiny baby bump. There at the front of the room at the funeral home was Mom, and I stood in the back near the door to say hello to people. I’m so sorry to hear about Lillian, they’d say. When are you due, in the next breath. My eyes filled and I nodded and answered the questions and screamed inside that this fate should befall first Mom, then me.
My darling girl kicked and squirmed as if to joyously respond to the proceedings, saying life goes on, telling me she would be there soon to cheer me up. In January, she arrived on time and healthy, and brought with her laughter and joy that was hard to fathom mere months earlier.
Mom and I were not very close, in those last few years, and every day I wish I could talk to her about this strange new world that she traversed before me. Motherhood took me mere months after she was released from it, and that transition has been poignant.
Unwittingly, Mom did leave me with one final lesson in those hard, bright August days. Motherhood is full of the unexpected; that is practically the textbook definition. And for every hard thing we must do, there is a smiling, kicking, giggling prize to balance it out.
-
I went to my mother’s funeral in a maternity dress, because I was five months pregnant.
I wasn’t planning on getting pregnant. My mother was diagnosed with ALS, Lou Gehrig’s disease, in the fall of 2008. I was anxious to avoid the emotional upheaval of pregnancy on top of the horror of my mother’s disease. It was a horror story from my childhood, in a way. Mom had been two months pregnant with me when her own mother died, and she never got to tell her. She told me the story over the years with tears in her eyes, bitterness in her voice. On some level, I promised, it wouldn’t happen to me.
Pregnancy and motherhood are really things that all the talks and reading in the world can’t prepare you for. But age-old motherly wisdom is supposed to be helpful. I wouldn’t really know. We never talked about it, and then when it happened, my mother couldn’t talk at all.
In the spring of 2011, working long hours and not paying close attention to birth control, I got pregnant. By this time, my mother was bedridden and could no longer smile or laugh. The second I knew for sure, I called to tell her, my dad holding the phone up to her ear. He told me she looked at him and he could tell she heard me, her eyes said everything.
My mother-in-law took me shopping for maternity clothes. We looked around at the nicer dresses, ones that I could later wear while breastfeeding. She told me to pick out something pretty, for going out to dinner. I picked something black, thinking I might need it for a funeral.
It is easy to spend a lot of time worrying about what can go wrong when you’re pregnant, especially when you carry the burden of genetic disorders. We have a history in our family of spina bifida, and I wanted, needed to talk to my mother about her experience when my brother was born with it – I wanted reassurance, I wanted to hear her refute the statistics and tell me my baby would be fine. When I asked, she blinked, the last thing she could do, and her gaze shifted away.
So I asked for every test I could get, not wanting to be caught off-guard. And everything was fine – I was tired, and that was all. My doctor grinned and told me, get more sleep. You’ll need it, he said.
It was difficult to accept all of this. It was strange, to know nothing was going wrong, when it seemed everyone I knew had a horror story – up to and including my own mother. And I was cursing the timing of it all. I was sad and angry, and had a hard time with joy in those first few months. It made me a terrible friend, and a hard person to get along with.
The call from my dad came late on a Friday afternoon. It was unbearably hot outside, the way Texas summers always are. The first time I felt nauseous while I was pregnant was in the wake of that phone call.
During her wake, I spent a lot of time answering questions about my tiny baby bump. There at the front of the room at the funeral home was Mom, and I stood in the back near the door to say hello to people. I’m so sorry to hear about Lillian, they’d say. When are you due, in the next breath. My eyes filled and I nodded and answered the questions and screamed inside that this fate should befall first Mom, then me.
My darling girl kicked and squirmed as if to joyously respond to the proceedings, saying life goes on, telling me she would be there soon to cheer me up. In January, she arrived on time and healthy, and brought with her laughter and joy that was hard to fathom mere months earlier.
Mom and I were not very close, in those last few years, and every day I wish I could talk to her about this strange new world that she traversed before me. Motherhood took me mere months after she was released from it, and that transition has been poignant.
Unwittingly, Mom did leave me with one final lesson in those hard, bright August days. Motherhood is full of the unexpected; that is practically the textbook definition. And for every hard thing we must do, there is a smiling, kicking, giggling prize to balance it out.
Sunday, May 13, 2012
mother's day
Four years ago today, I had the most memorable phone conversation I ever experienced with my mother. I had called her to wish her a happy Mother's Day. Our conversation was short, maybe ten minutes long. I did most of the talking. When she spoke, I couldn't understand her. I turned up the volume, I asked her to repeat herself, I wondered for a minute if my hearing was bad. When we hung up, I looked over at my husband and said, "I think something is wrong with Mom."
That was the day that the months, probably years, of subtle signs of her illness became glaring. Mom's speech was slurred and thick. I remember telling Randy that I thought she sounded drunk, and that was absurd, because she didn't really drink, and it was midday besides. As the day wore on, the dread sunk in, became fear. Before the week was out, I had emailed my dad to tell him I thought she might have ALS. She had a doctor's appointment coming up and I wanted to make sure someone told the doctor this. Because you know, there is no test for it. There's just elimination. They test you for cancer, for thyroid disease, heart disease, for obscure nerve illnesses. Mom's official diagnosis happened in September 2008. But the day that sticks in my heart is Mother's Day.
I can't help feeling that this day is always going to be haunted. But when Randy brought Annalise into our room this morning to wake me up, her dimples and giggle put things right. I won't pretend today wasn't bittersweet, because it was. My little girl, though, gave me a day to remember that balances that terrible moment.
All I can tell you today is to hug your mom. Call her. Listen to her voice. I promise it won't be a wasted moment. I used to think such pleas and reminders were terribly cliche - and maybe they are, but there are so many of us who can't call our mothers today.
Also, fittingly, May is ALS Awareness Month. Take a moment to find out what this disease is and what it has done to too many families.
Finally - Mom and me, in 1981.
That was the day that the months, probably years, of subtle signs of her illness became glaring. Mom's speech was slurred and thick. I remember telling Randy that I thought she sounded drunk, and that was absurd, because she didn't really drink, and it was midday besides. As the day wore on, the dread sunk in, became fear. Before the week was out, I had emailed my dad to tell him I thought she might have ALS. She had a doctor's appointment coming up and I wanted to make sure someone told the doctor this. Because you know, there is no test for it. There's just elimination. They test you for cancer, for thyroid disease, heart disease, for obscure nerve illnesses. Mom's official diagnosis happened in September 2008. But the day that sticks in my heart is Mother's Day.
I can't help feeling that this day is always going to be haunted. But when Randy brought Annalise into our room this morning to wake me up, her dimples and giggle put things right. I won't pretend today wasn't bittersweet, because it was. My little girl, though, gave me a day to remember that balances that terrible moment.
All I can tell you today is to hug your mom. Call her. Listen to her voice. I promise it won't be a wasted moment. I used to think such pleas and reminders were terribly cliche - and maybe they are, but there are so many of us who can't call our mothers today.
Also, fittingly, May is ALS Awareness Month. Take a moment to find out what this disease is and what it has done to too many families.
Finally - Mom and me, in 1981.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

